Batman #668, by Grant Morrison and J.H. Williams III, is an excellent comic book. As the second installment of the three-part “Club of Heroes” story, it expands the story both inwardly and outwardly, creating a metafictional context for the Agatha Christie-inspired mystery while advancing the murderous plot.
, and Batman having remained a much darker incarnation of himself ever since the mid 1980s). Throughout the issue, Morrison and Williams III play with the resonance of the past on the events of the present.
Actually, Morrison seems to be playing with that theme throughout his Batman run. As much as his iteration of Batman is self-declared attempt to return the character to the Neal Adams “hairy-chested love God” version, and as much as Morrison explores the nature of Batman doppelgangers and variations, the dominant idea throughout all of Morrison’s issues so far seems to be the legacy of the past. Batman had to deal with the consequences of his tryst with Talia, he’s re-opened the “Black Casebook” which is his attempt to reconcile the supernatural and science-fictional elements of his history, and now, Batman’s reunion with minor (some would say ridiculous) characters from his past has resulted in tragedy. Even the much-maligned prose issue featuring “The Clown at Midnight,” fits into that scheme, since Morrison’s Joker is terrifying exactly because he constantly reinvents himself with no regard for the past. He’s a character without the weight of a consistent legacy, and that’s where his evil derives.
Batman #668 fits firmly into that thematic structure, but that’s not necessarily what makes it good. What makes it good is Morrison’s use of Batman as as detective, the expansiveness of the implied mythology of these minor characters, and the stunning work by J.H. Williams III.
First, the detective bits. As I’ve mentioned elsewhere, Batman rarely uses his supposed detective skills. Even in Paul Dini’s earlier Detective Comics stories, which are pretty good self-contained stories, the Riddler plays the role of the detective, and then Batman kind of explains what was really going on in the end. We don’t see Batman doing much detecting throughout the course of the stories. And most writers ignore the detective stuff entirely, moving from one fight or pursuit to another, without much care in the small details of observation.
Since those pieces are often ignored, it’s nice to see Morrison taking advantage of that side of Batman. It’s not like the issue is revolutionary in the way it shows these detective moments, but it’s nice to see. Morrison gives us clues, like the number of times the Legionary was killed, and a card with a bit of Latin. He gives us chicken grease and a mysterious light source. These are conventions of the detective genre, nothing we haven’t seen on television before, but they’re conventions because they are an intrinsic part of that type of mystery story. And that’s what Batman #668 is–beneath all the “legacy of the past” stuff and the metafictional representations of the “Batmen,” drawn in the styles of various other arists — it’s a mystery story. A good one. I don’t know whodunit, but I’m curious to find out.
Second, Morrison and Williams III use the iconography of comic books (both verbal and visual) to create an entire mythology around the Club of Heroes — characters who made less than a handful of appearances in previous stories and were created to represent what their original name impled. They were the “Batmen of All Nations,” and their characterization was a stereotypical as their costumes. The French Batman looked like Musketeer (hence his name), the Native American Batman wore feathers, the British Batman was a knight, etc. While Williams III draws each character in a way which implies that each of them has undergone revisionism (which I won’t go into here, since I covered it in my review of #667), and thereby uses a visual shorthand to imply a depth of characterization (even a stereotypical one) missing from the Club’s previous appearances, Morrison uses apparently throw-away lines of dialogue to refer to a world outside the story. The Musketeer refers to “those years in prison” and his “old adversary Pierrot Lunaire,” the Legionary lost his city to “a madman called Charlie Caligula,” and the Gaucho explains that “the blue scorpion is the calling card of the assassin Scorpiana.” Yes, those are ridiculous character names that match the stereotypical portrayal of these “Batmen,” but they imply the Morrison has created histories for these sad, doomed heroes. Scorpiana, Charlie Caligula, and Pierrot Lunaire will doubtful play any kind of role in the story (I doubt they are clues, although I don’t know for sure), but just by mentioning them in the story, the issue feels larger, more expansive, and more imaginative. It’s basically a locked-room mystery that takes place in the world between the imagined past, the “real” past of Batman, and the recontextualized present.
Third, Williams III is in top form in this story. The conceit of illustrating each character in the mode of another artist (or style) could be a disaster, and I can see how a reader might find it off-putting even in this issue, but I think Williams III pulls it off brilliantly. One could argue, perhaps, that it’s a bit like watching Who Framed Roger Rabbit, with all the competing layers and character designs clashing against one another. But that’s where its beauty lies. It’s a self-aware approach to comic book art, surely, but the clash of styles acts not only as a visual shorthand (as I mentioned above), but it matches the lack of harmony within the Club of Heroes as well. They clash, both artistically and personally. It fits.
But Williams III doesn’t stop there, with his artistic playfulness. He uses a batwing design to frame a sequence, interrupted by the sillouette of a black gloved hand (representing the machinations of the mysterious villain). And in a virtuoso two-page spread in the climax of issue, he justaposes three layers: a six-panel top layer, with the final three panels falling off into the following page as the climactic image is revealed beneath; a glove-shaped panel as the middle layer, revealing the death of another victim; and two partly-obscured nine-panel grids as the bottom layer, revealing the romaticized, sweetly naive past of the victim. It connects the legacy of the past theme with the thriller plot and emphasizes the level of the threat while showing character reactions. All done with style and beauty. It’s a remarkable two pages.
Fourth, rereading JLA #16 (cover-dated March 1998) recently, I was struck by an interesting convergence between Batman #668 and this nearly ten-year-old Justice League story. I’m not surprised by the convergence, especially since I wrote an entire book about the recurring patterns in Morrison’s work, but it was interesting enough to make me think about the way ideas and images are often recycled.
If you remember your 1990s comics, you’d recall that JLA #16 features the villain Prometheus (who had posed as the heroic Retro — winner of the “Join the JLA for a Day” contest) and his attempt to infiltrate the Watchtower and eliminate the League members one at a time. Take a look at his dialogue in this panel here. “I’m taking them down one by one,” he says. “Ten Little Indians.”
This is, of course, exactly the premise (and Agatha Christie plot) that we see in the current Batman #668. The difference is in the execution, as the JLA story is full of super-hero bombast and fisticuffs while the Batman story is all mood and suspense. Nevertheless, it’s a clear example of Morrison returning to tell almost the same story after nearly a decade. (And, in both cases, the story seems to be one of the highlights of his run on the titles.)
Another convergence, from the very same JLA story, comes on the page immediately following Prometheus’s Agatha Christie allusion. As you can see here, a crooked house appears, representing entrapment in Limbo (Limbo turns out to be Prometheus’s base of operations, as he’s a “crooked man,” and in the JLA #16 story, he teleports the angel Zauriel there for safekeeping). This image of a crooked house seems to converge with Batman #668 also, specifically with the J.H. Williams III cover.
In issue #668, Batman is never literally shown inside a twisted house — the cover is a symbolic image, showing the hero trapped helplessly in a disorienting environment as the grip of the Black Glove threatens his life. The house is a metaphor, on the cover, of his current emotional state. It’s not much of a stretch to connect that convergence with yet another: Arkham Asylum – a graphic novel predicated on the idea that a house (the asylum) is the fragmented psyche of Batman.
I don’t know if Morrison directed Williams III to depict a type of crooked house on the cover of Batman #668, but the covergence remains. The patterns continue. To make a convergence of our own, let’s recall the words of the multi-dimensional being Iok Sotot from Morrison’s first major super-hero comic: Zenith. He blissfully declares, “I love to watch the mindless patterns they make in spacetime.”
Morrison’s Batman run has been interesting since the beginning, but his collaboration with Williams III has moved this three-issue arc into the top tier of Morrison super-hero stories. Batman #668 is not only the best comic of the week, but I think the “Club of Heroes” will be remembered as one of the Batman highlights of the decade.